HomeFeaturesDailyBriefingsRapidReconSpecial ReportsAbout Us

Moral Equivalence and Terrorism

In Tuesday's Chicago Tribune, Alan Dershowitz takes aim at the harm done by the display of moral equivalence on the part of Kofi Annan in his commentary How the UN legitimizes terrorists. It should be considered required reading.

If anyone wonders why the UN has rendered itself worse than irrelevant in the Arab-Israeli conflict, all he or she need do is read UN Secretary General Kofi Annan's July 20 statement. Annan goes to great pains to suggest equal fault and moral equivalence between the rockets of Hezbollah and Hamas that specifically target innocent civilians and the self-defense efforts by Israel, which tries desperately, though not always successfully, to avoid causing civilian casualties. In his statement, Annan never condemns, or even mentions, terrorism, which is a root cause and precipitator of the conflict.

Even Annan was forced to acknowledge that "Hezbollah's provocative attack on July 12 was the trigger of this particular crisis"; that Hezbollah is "deliberate[ly] targeting ... Israeli population centers with hundreds of indiscriminate weapons"; and that Israel has the "right to defend itself under Article 51 of the UN charter." But he doesn't stop there. He goes out of his way to insist on equating Hezbollah's terrorists with Israeli military response, which he labels "disproportionate" and "collective punishment." He condemns both Hezbollah and Israel. He also criticizes Israel for its efforts at preventing Qassam rocket attacks against its civilian populations, noting that the Hamas rockets have produced no "casualties in the past month." (This, of course, is not for lack of trying.) He ignores Hamas' long history of terrorism against innocent civilians.

The key phrase is "This, of course, is not for lack of trying."

The difference between the two sides is intent and target selection. Their rockets and suicide bombers seek out civilians - the former by the cities, the latter by the busloads.

We ask yet one more time:

What if Hizballah or Hamas had Merkavas?